That user is saying that the fact that Russians face more danger for protesting means that any lack of protest reflects less poorly on Russian people than on Americans
And, as I said, Americans face plenty of risk too, but only if they do the kinds of protests that actually might achieve something. No, the US government isn’t going to murder a protester’s entire family, but they will lock up the breadwinner and leave the kids with no safety net programs. Plus, you can forget ever getting a decent job once you have a conviction on your record. Americans also have more, so they have more to lose. The risks are different, but just as real.
You are making a separate argument.
Of course I am. It would be pretty silly to make the same (bad) argument - even flipping the sides. Do you think they are prepared to admit that the US has more freedom, because I sincerely doubt it.
the average American is fairly content (and often even thrilled) to live with the violence their government has perpetrated
Absolutely false. These foreign interventions are always extremely unpopular, including the topic at hand. The ruling class is another matter entirely, but average Americans do not back these interventions. I will agree they have a tendency to ignore many of the less noisy interventions, but that’s true everywhere. If things are working in people’s favor, they don’t tend to dwell on them - unfortunately.
Also, the majority of Americans do not support Trump or the Republicans. Were it not for our fucked up election system and a whole lot of help from mother Russia, the Republicans would have zero power at the national level.
How familiar are you with recent Russian history?
Familiar enough. I’m not unsympathetic, but it doesn’t invalidate anybody the arguments I made.
people are obviously terrified that life will go back to how it was in the 90s before he took power.
You don’t think that MAGA is motivated by terror? Rural America is collapsing, and they have been taught to fear the cities their entire lives, not to mention the fact that they have no skills to get a job there, and no money to find a place to live. Russia has no monopoly on fear.
This judgement of blaming Russian “culture” for this rather than the neoliberal shock therapy
How familiar are you with extended Russian history? Russia was like this long before they could blame it on “the west”. I do blame Russian culture, just like I blame American (especially southern) culture for it’s problems. We’ve all got cultural baggage.
rampant nazism and social murder of the 1990s
Bullshit. There is no more Nazism in the US than anywhere else - at least until fairly recently. (And it would be great if the Nazis weren’t all getting Russian funding). There has certainly been an odor of fascism in the neoliberal consensus. I’ll give you that but, again, I’m not sure America is different from anywhere else in that regard.







How do you come to this conclusion? What I see is the administration consistently failing to execute on their domestic agenda and backing down. Their National Guard deployments were shut down by the courts. ICE is nowhere close to meeting their stated goals, and becoming less popular by the hour. They can’t even fill the positions they have, nevermind growing it larger with the new budget. Even Jimmy Kimmel is still on the air.